What's a Healthy Blood Sugar? Prediabetes Explained with Dr. Kerry Reller

November 18, 2026

Prediabetes is one of the most common things found on routine labs, and one of the most fixable. In this post, Dr. Kerry Reller explains what a healthy blood sugar really is, the difference between "normal" and "optimal," what insulin resistance is, the signs to watch for, and how to turn prediabetes around, with or without medication.

What Is Blood Sugar?

Blood sugar is the amount of glucose, one of the body's natural sugars, in your blood. Your body works hard to keep it in a safe range. If it drops too low or climbs too high, it can be dangerous, even life threatening.

What's a Healthy Blood Sugar? Normal vs. Optimal

Just because a lab result isn't flagged in red doesn't mean it's where your body does best. Lab ranges are often based on averages, not on where you should really live.

  • Fasting blood sugar, standard normal: Under 100 mg/dL, measured first thing in the morning before eating.

  • Fasting blood sugar, what I consider optimal: Roughly 60 to 80 mg/dL. When I see 80 to 99 mg/dL, I start a conversation about possible insulin resistance instead of brushing it off.

  • A1C: Your average blood sugar over about three months, roughly the life span of a red blood cell. I like to see about 4.9 to 5.3%, which works out to an average glucose of roughly 94 to 105 mg/dL.

  • An early warning A1C: At 5.5 to 5.6%, I start talking with patients about insulin resistance.

What Numbers Mean Prediabetes or Diabetes?

These are the official American Diabetes Association criteria.

  • A1C: Prediabetes is 5.7 to 6.4%. Diabetes is 6.5% or higher.

  • Fasting glucose: Prediabetes is 100 to 125 mg/dL. Diabetes is 126 mg/dL or higher.

  • 2-hour glucose tolerance test: Prediabetes is 140 to 199 mg/dL. Diabetes is 200 mg/dL or higher.

  • Random glucose: 200 mg/dL or higher with classic symptoms like frequent urination and extreme thirst also points to diabetes.

Without obvious high blood sugar, a diabetes diagnosis needs to be confirmed with a second test.

What Is Insulin Resistance?

Insulin works like a key. When it attaches to a cell, it unlocks the door so glucose can move inside and be used for energy. With insulin resistance, the cells stop listening to insulin as well, so glucose has a harder time getting in and starts to build up in the blood.

Here's the sneaky part. Your pancreas fights back by making more and more insulin to force the glucose in. So for years, your blood sugar and A1C can look normal while your insulin runs high behind the scenes. That's why I often check a fasting insulin along with fasting glucose and calculate a score called HOMA-IR. It can catch the problem early, long before the glucose numbers creep up.

High insulin matters on its own, too. It's a fat storage hormone that tends to add weight around the belly, and it's linked to fatty liver, high triglycerides, high blood pressure and PCOS.

What Are the Signs of Insulin Resistance?

  • A larger waist: Common US cutoffs are over 40 inches for men and over 35 inches for women. Some groups use lower numbers, especially for people of Asian descent.

  • Skin changes: Acanthosis nigricans, a dark, velvety skin change on the back of the neck or under the arms, and skin tags.

  • How you feel after meals: Tired or foggy after eating, hungry again soon after, or craving sugar.

  • Stubborn weight: Trouble losing weight, especially around the middle.

  • Lab clues: High triglycerides, low HDL, high blood pressure or fatty liver.

  • Hormone clues: Irregular periods or PCOS in women.

Once it progresses to diabetes, you may notice frequent urination, extreme thirst, blurry vision, slow-healing cuts, frequent infections, tingling in the feet or unexplained weight loss.

Can Prediabetes Be Reversed?

Absolutely. In the large Diabetes Prevention Program study, lifestyle changes lowered the risk of developing diabetes by 58%, with about 7% weight loss and 150 minutes of activity a week. Small changes add up.

  • Move more: Active muscles soak up glucose from the blood.

  • Build muscle: More muscle means more places for glucose to go.

  • Eat fewer carbohydrates: This lowers how much insulin your body needs to release.

  • Sleep well: And get treated if you have sleep apnea.

  • Manage stress: High cortisol pushes blood sugar up.

When Are Medications Used?

When you're ready and a good candidate. You don't have to "fail" lifestyle changes first. If you're asking for more support, you've probably been trying on your own for a while.

  • Metformin: A great starting point. It helps your cells respond better to insulin, it's inexpensive, it's been used for decades and it's usually well tolerated. Many people see modest weight loss, often a few pounds and sometimes more. Researchers are also studying whether it may help with healthy aging and dementia risk, but that isn't proven yet.

  • GLP-1 medications: Another option, especially if metformin doesn't agree with you. Through the Medicare GLP-1 Bridge program, Medicare patients with prediabetes and a BMI of 27 or higher may qualify for certain GLP-1 medications for $50 a month. The program runs from July 1, 2026, through December 31, 2027.

Treating prediabetes early helps prevent problems down the road. Please talk with your provider before starting or changing any medication.

Key Takeaways

  • Normal isn't always optimal: A fasting blood sugar under 100 is "normal," but 60 to 80 mg/dL is a better place to live.

  • Know the prediabetes numbers: An A1C of 5.7 to 6.4%, a fasting glucose of 100 to 125 mg/dL or a 2-hour test of 140 to 199 mg/dL.

  • Insulin resistance comes first: High insulin can hide behind normal blood sugar for years, so a fasting insulin and HOMA-IR can catch it early.

  • Lifestyle changes work: Modest weight loss and regular activity cut diabetes risk by more than half.

  • Medication is an option when you're ready: Metformin and GLP-1 medications can add support.

Conclusion

Start now. Don't let prediabetes turn into diabetes. There's no reason it has to. With or without medication, you can turn things around, and you can start feeling better today. Call (727) 446-1097 or visit cfma.health to schedule a visit in Clearwater or Palm Harbor.

Dr. Kerry Reller, MD

Dr. Kerry Reller, MD

Dr. Kerry Reller is a board certified family medicine and obesity medicine physician and the owner of Clearwater Family Medicine and Allergy, with offices in Clearwater and Palm Harbor, Florida. Dr. Reller provides primary care, allergy and asthma care, medical weight management and menopause care, and hosts the Get Healthy Tampa Bay Podcast. Our mission is to serve our patients with exceptional, timely, quality care using up-to-date, evidence-based medicine.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog