
Dr. Alex Reyes on Perimenopause Myths, WHI, and Modern Hormone Therapy Options
For more than 20 years, fear has kept many women from treatment that could help them feel like themselves again. In this episode of the Get Healthy Tampa Bay Podcast, Dr. Kerry Reller talks with Dr. Alexandria Reyes, a board-certified OB-GYN and menopause specialist with Magnolia Gynecology in South Tampa, about the myths around hormone therapy, what the research really shows and why the FDA's recent removal of the black box warning matters.
Why Menopause Care Has Been Hard to Find
Dr. Reyes started her career in general OB-GYN and fertility care before focusing entirely on perimenopause, menopause and hormone care about five years ago. She explains that most doctors, including OB-GYNs, receive very little menopause training in medical school or residency, and perimenopause, the 10 or so years before periods stop, is discussed even less. Learning to treat it well usually takes extra training and mentorship.
The Women's Health Initiative: What Really Happened
In 2002, the Women's Health Initiative (WHI), a large and well-designed randomized controlled trial, was reported in the media in a way that frightened women. Many stopped their hormones overnight. What often gets lost:
The women studied were not typical: Their average age was 63, and many already had diabetes or heart disease, unlike a healthy 45-year-old with new hot flashes.
The hormones were different: The study used synthetic estrogen and a synthetic progestin, not the body-identical estradiol and micronized progesterone commonly prescribed today.
Estrogen alone did not raise breast cancer risk: In fact, the estrogen-only group had a lower risk of breast cancer.
The combined group's increase was small: Women taking estrogen plus a synthetic progestin had a slight increase in absolute risk, similar to the risk from drinking alcohol regularly, carrying extra weight or not exercising.
There were real benefits: The WHI provides some of the best evidence that estrogen protects bone density.
Key Takeaways
Body-identical hormones are preferred: Transdermal estradiol (patches, gels or sprays) does not go through the liver and is not linked to the same clot and stroke risks, and micronized progesterone is gentler on the heart and breast.
There is no hard stop date: About 15% of women still have hot flashes and night sweats more than 10 years after their last period. The Menopause Society no longer recommends automatically stopping at a certain age. Decisions should be individualized.
"Hormone receptor positive" does not mean hormones caused cancer: Most breast cancers have hormone receptors, just like normal breast tissue, and these tumors are often easier to treat.
Hormone therapy should not be a last resort: For many women it is the right first-line treatment, rather than antidepressants, sleep aids or Benadryl, which carry their own risks.
The Black Box Warning Is Gone
Because of the WHI, every estrogen product, even low-dose vaginal estrogen that barely enters the bloodstream, carried the FDA's most serious black box warning for more than 20 years. Many women read it at home and never used the prescription. After advocacy from menopause experts, the FDA recently removed the warning. Dr. Reyes hopes it will open more conversations, since only about 4% of eligible women have been taking hormone therapy, even though most women have symptoms at some point.
It Is Not Just Hot Flashes
Estrogen receptors are found throughout the body, so perimenopause and menopause can affect nearly every system. Symptoms can begin in the mid-to-late 30s or early 40s and include:
Hot flashes and night sweats
Anxiety, depression, irritability or new or worse PMS-type mood changes
Trouble sleeping, even without night sweats
Vaginal dryness, painful sex, urinary urgency and frequency, and more urinary tract infections
Joint pain and autoimmune flares
Heart palpitations
Brain fog and trouble finding words
Dry eyes and dry mouth
Weight gain, constipation and worse acid reflux
Shorter menstrual cycles, such as every 24 days instead of every 28, or changes in flow
Simply not feeling like yourself
Many women see a cardiologist, rheumatologist and endocrinologist and are told everything is normal before anyone considers perimenopause.
Affordable, FDA-Approved Options
Dr. Reyes prefers the term "body identical" over "bioidentical," which is often a marketing term for compounded hormones. FDA-approved estradiol and progesterone are body identical, have consistent quality control and are often much cheaper. Patches are usually the most accessible and best covered, and pharmacies like Mark Cuban's Cost Plus Drugs or membership options like HRT Club can lower costs. Side effects usually mean the dose or formulation needs adjusting, since treatment is both an art and a science.
Conclusion
If you do not feel like yourself, you are probably right that something has changed. Hormonal shifts affect quality of life, relationships and how vibrantly you age. If your doctor has not been able to help, seek another opinion from someone with menopause expertise. Dr. Reyes sees patients virtually throughout Florida and in person in South Tampa.
About Our Guest
Dr. Alexandria Reyes is the private practice owner and founder of Magnolia Gynecology in Tampa, Florida, and also the owner of a virtual menopause care practice, serving the entire state of Florida. She has dedicated her practice to midlife and menopause care, offering compassionate virtual care and comprehensive education on all menopause and hormone therapy options. Dr. Reyes empowers all going through the menopause transition, including survivors of hormone-sensitive and gynecologic cancers, to confidently navigate midlife and make informed, personalized choices for their health, longevity, and well-being.
Dr. Reyes completed her undergraduate education at Kansas State University, earning honors in Food Science. She earned her medical degree, with honors, at Kansas City University of Medicine and Biosciences and completed her residency in Obstetrics and Gynecology at the University of Kansas School of Medicine, Wichita.
Dr. Reyes is Board Certified in Obstetrics and Gynecology and a Menopause Society Certified Practitioner.
Connect with Dr. Reyes
Listen to the full episode on the Get Healthy Tampa Bay Podcast: Dr. Alex Reyes on Perimenopause Myths, WHI, and Modern Hormone Therapy Options
Listen and Learn More
Watch the full episode above or listen to the Get Healthy Tampa Bay Podcast on your favorite podcast app. To schedule a visit with Dr. Kerry Reller at Clearwater Family Medicine and Allergy in Clearwater or Palm Harbor, call (727) 446-1097.
